Should I file contempt against boss if court direction not complied with?

Tilak Marg Forum for Legal Questions Forums Service and Labour Laws Should I file contempt against boss if court direction not complied with?

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    Posts
    • #1934
      Anonymous
      Guest

      Struggled for 3 years in court and then won the case against department. Their appeal in high court also dismissed. Still the government not complied with court order. My advocate told me to file contempt petition against my boss, who is joint secretary rank (I am only class 2 level officer). But my worry is that if I file contempt against my own boss, what will happen to my career? He can spoil my career completely if he has to go to jail for contempt? Further if he is not complying with present court order, will he comply with contempt also? Pl. advise whether I should file contempt or there is some other method.

    • #1947

      Look, you have mentioned that you have already fought against the department for last 3 years and have won the case in the first court and then in the appellate court also. So, it is not that you are fighting with the department for the first time. Have you seen any victimisation or harassment merely because you went to the court / tribunal against the department?

      When the department is not complying with the order of the courts which was in your favour, what is your remedy if you do not file contempt of court against the officer responsible for not implementing the order? Generally, contempt petition is utilized for forcing implementation of the orders of the court, under the threat of the contempt. So, there is nothing unusual if you file the contempt petition against your boss. In fact, he should know that if he neglects to implement the court order, contempt would be one of the consequences. At the same time, if you feel that he is not aware of the orders of the court or that the juniors in the department are deliberately hiding the court orders from him, you may seek an appointment with him to apprise him about the court orders, or send him request letters, or send him formal notice of your intent to file a contempt petition in the appropriate court if the order is not implemented within a reasonable period of time, which you may specify in your notice. And, of course, you should wait for a reasonable period of time before you ultimately file a contempt petition in the court.

      I may also point out that it is very rare that some officer of the Government is actually punished for contempt. In most of the cases, under the threat of the impending contempt of court, the order of the court is implemented due to which the contempt proceedings are thereafter dropped and nothing happens to the contemnor.

      So, there is nothing unusual if you file a contempt petition to force your department to implement the court orders in your favour.

           


      Dr. Ashok Dhamija is a New Delhi based Supreme Court Advocate and author of law books. Read more about him by clicking here. List of his Forum Replies. List of his other articles. List of his Quora Answers. List of his YouTube Videos.

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • The forum ‘Service and Labour Laws’ is closed to new Questions and replies.