Home Opinion Can previous penalties be made a fresh charge / ground for imposing...

Can previous penalties be made a fresh charge / ground for imposing another penalty in departmental proceedings?

3
0
Supreme Court

In departmental proceedings, it is quite common that a charge memorandum issued to an employee also contains a charge / allegation that the employee was punished on previous occasions. Often there are such charges / allegations made and references to past conduct in the charges raised against an employee and basing on such past conduct / past penalties, a negative inference is taken against the said employee. The question that arises for consideration is whether the previous penalties for which an employee has already been punished can be treated as a fresh misconduct and can be made a basis for imposing fresh penalty.

The Supreme Court comprising a bench of Hon’ble Mr. Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh in the case of Sumit Kumar v. Union of India & Ors., 2026 INSC 1221 : SLP(C) No. 28027-28028 of 2024 has answered this question. In the instant case, the Appellant – Sumit Kumar had joined the CISF as a constable in the year 2012. In the year 2017, his wife suffered a miscarriage and had to undergo surgeries for which the Appellant availed leave. The said leave was extended once. His request for further extension of leave was rejected and on 06.12.2017, the Appellant stating that he is under acute mental stress due to his wife’s medical condition tendered his resignation on the grievance portal. His resignation request was rejected and on inspection his leave was further extended. He thereafter resumed his duty on 17.12.2017 and was transferred to another unit where he joined on 18.01.2018.

On joining at his new posting, the department issued a charge memorandum to him under Rule 36 of the CISF Rule 2001 containing three charges. The first charge was that he had not appeared before the Commandant despite directions and that the Appellant tendered his conditional resignation to pressurize the administration. Second charge was pertaining to a video wherein his wife had accused the administration of torturing the Appellant by not giving him a leave and that he threatened the administration by making the said video viral. Third charge pertained to the five minor penalties during his service tenure and that the Appellant despite the previous 5 minor penalties did not mend his ways.

The disciplinary authority imposed the penalty of “removal of service from immediate effect” on the Appellant and as such he was removed. The Appeal before the DIG and IG were both dismissed. The Appellant thereafter filed a Writ Petition before the Delhi High Court bearing WP(C) No. 8173 of 2020 whereby the High Court also dismissed the Writ Petition and observed that the Appellant had a chequered service history and that he was a habitual offender and observed that “a blot is a blot, be it of the slightest degree, the magnitude thereof is of little importance.” It further held that the Appellant had displayed no remorse and had been evasive throughout the proceedings, that the departmental enquiry had been conducted in terms of the CISF Rules, 2001, and that the punishment of removal from service was commensurate with his conduct and the charges levelled against him.

It would be imperative to first analyse the other judgments on this point before going into the case of Sumit Kumar.

The Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda, AIR 1964 SC 506 : Civil Appeal No. 387 of 1963, held that under Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India, if the proposed punishment is also based on the previous punishments or previous bad record of a Government servant, the same must be included in the second show cause notice so that the government servant may be able to give an explanation. Interestingly, the Hon’ble Court also dealt with the suggestion that past record ought to be made a specific charge at the first stage itself, and observed as under:

“But it is not necessary in this case to decide whether such previous record can be made the subject matter of charge at the first stage of the enquiry. But, nothing in law prevents the punishing authority from taking that fact into consideration during the second stage of the enquiry, for essentially it, relates more to the domain of punishment rather than to that of guilt. But what is essential is that the Government servant shall be given a reasonable opportunity to know that fact and meet the same.”

Subsequently, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of India & Ors. v. Bishamber Das Dogra, (2009) 13 SCC 102 : Civil Appeal No. 7087 of 2002, interestingly also a case of a CISF personnel who was punished on three earlier occasions for absence, explained the principle laid down in K. Manche Gowda (supra) and held as under:

“18. In State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda, this Court held that the disciplinary authority should inform the delinquent employee that it is likely to take into consideration the past conduct of the employee while imposing the punishment unless the proved charge against the delinquent is so grave that it may independently warrant the proposed punishment. Though his previous record may not be the subject-matter of the charge at the first instance.

…

25. In view of the above, it is evident that it is desirable that the delinquent employee may be informed by the disciplinary authority that his past conduct would be taken into consideration while imposing the punishment. But in case of misconduct of grave nature or indiscipline, even in the absence of statutory rules, the authority may take into consideration the indisputable past conduct/service record of the employee for adding the weight to the decision of imposing the punishment if the facts of the case so require.”

The said position was reiterated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Punjab & Ors. v. Ex. C. Satpal Singh, 2025 INSC 1056 : Civil Appeal No. 312 of 2012 wherein, a police constable was dismissed from service for unauthorised absence of 37 days and the dismissal order also made a reference to his earlier punishments, which were not disclosed in the show cause notice. The Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana had set aside the dismissal by relying upon K. Manche Gowda (supra). Setting aside the judgment of the High Court, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under:

“31. In light of the judicial precedents cited above, when the factual matrix of the present case is appreciated, it is seen that the reference to the fact of forfeiture of 17 years of service of the respondent as a result of his absence from service on previous occasions was in exclusion or independent of the misconduct for which the enquiry officer has found him guilty. The consideration of the past misconduct of the respondent was not the effective reason for dismissing him from the service. The disciplinary authority had mentioned the past misconduct of the respondent only for adding the weight to the decision of imposing the punishment.”

A bare perusal of the abovementioned judgments of the Supreme Court makes it clear that the past record of a government servant may be taken into consideration by the disciplinary authority at the time of deciding the quantum of the punishment for a misconduct which was proved. However, in the instant case of Sumit Kumar, the previous penalties were not merely referred to at the stage of imposing punishment but in fact they were made a separate charge in itself. The Hon’ble Supreme Court after holding that the first two charges were not proved against the Appellant observed as follows:

“20. A perusal of the third charge reveals that it refers to five previous minor penalties imposed upon the Appellant and alleges that, despite the opportunities afforded to him, he had failed to mend his ways. The previous misconduct for which an employee has already been subjected to disciplinary action cannot, by itself, be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct for the purpose of imposing another penalty. The past service record may, where relevant and in accordance with the applicable rules, be considered while determining the penalty for a subsequent misconduct which has independently been established. It cannot, however, be used to supply the deficiency in proof of the charges in the present proceedings. In the present case, the reference to previous minor penalties does not establish any independent misconduct forming part of the present proceedings, nor can it be used to strengthen charges which have otherwise not been proved.”

Therefore, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that merely because penalties have been imposed upon a government servant in the past, a fresh punishment cannot be accorded to him on that account alone. The past record can be considered while determining the penalty, but only for a misconduct which has been independently established. The former penalties cannot by themselves be the basis for imposing punishment, nor can they be used to strengthen charges which have not been proved.

The Supreme Court in Sumit Kumar further noticed certain procedural irregularities in the conduct of the inquiry. The documents relied upon in the charge memorandum were in English, a language in which the Appellant was not conversant. Despite his request for translation of the documents into Hindi, the same was rejected and the translated copies were supplied to him only after the evidence was recorded and closed. The Supreme Court observed that, “The supply of translated copies at such a belated stage deprived the Appellant of an effective opportunity to understand the material relied upon against him and to prepare his defence.” It was further observed that the Appellant’s request to seek the assistance of a defence assistant was wrongly rejected, despite the same being provided for under Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules, 2001. These irregularities, the Court observed, reinforced its conclusion. Accordingly, the order of removal was set aside as being shockingly disproportionate and the Appellant was directed to be reinstated with all consequential benefits and 50% back wages.

Summing up, in Bishamber Das Dogra and Satpal Singh, the question was whether the past record can be considered at the stage of punishment and in Sumit Kumar the past record was made as a charge itself. Therefore, reading the three judgments together, it is clear that while the past record may be used for adding weight to the punishment for misconduct which has independently been proved, the same cannot be treated as a fresh misconduct nor can it be used to fill the gaps while proving the other charges.